Standardized Testing
The case against standardized testing: raising the scores, ruining the schools
By Alfie Kohn
http://teacherrenewal.wiki.westga.edu/file/view/Testing,+Testing,+Testing.pdf/227207662/Testing,%20Testing,%20Testing.pdfStandardized testing is a huge topic in all schools. Many students are stressed about taking the exams and doing well. But are the tests a good reflection of how the student is growing in the classroom? Every student is different, so a test should not define how they are doing in school.
SECTION 1: Kinds of Tests
The worst tests that are given are multiple choice tests. Multiple choice tests do not show what a student is able to do. They may get the answer correct, but it does not mean that the student knows the answer. The answer could have just been a guess for all we know. " Students are unable to generate a response; all they can do is recognize one by picking it out of four or five answers provided by someone else. They can't even explain their reasons for choosing the answer they did."
This matters because students are given tests that do not even show the growth in the classroom. The answers are not even based on what the student thinks because they are someone else's words. Students are assessed by a test that does not really even say too much about them. It is a good thing that the tests also include response questions because teachers can assess where their students are at in the classroom.
For example:"Obviously some sort of remembering, calculating, or thinking has to be done to figure out which answer is "most appropriate," but other sorts of mental operations (such as organizing information or constructing an argument) are pretty much excluded by the format. No matter how clever or tricky the questions are, a multiple-choice test simply "does not measure the same cognitive skills as are measured by similar problems in free-response form," as one expert explained in a now-classic article. The difference between the two formats (which is to say, the limits of multiple-choice questions) really shows up when the idea is to measure "complex cognitive problem-solving skills.""
The takeaways are that teachers should be aware that the standardized tests do not fully assess the students. The students should be tested on the response questions because they write their thoughts and ideas down, rather than picking an answer that is 'most appropriate' or in someone else's words.
SECTION 2: What the Standardized Tests Cannot Measure.
Standardized tests measure how a student calculates math or how many answers they get correct, but they do not measure creativity, effort, etc. The tests that are given to students do not measure what truly matters, not answers that do not show what a student is really capable of. Students should not be tested on content that they need to memorize, but they should be tested on their conceptual thinking, judgement, etc.
This matters because as educators, we need to make sure that students are creative and put their own twist on assignments to make it theirs. Students should not be tested on the same material because no one is the same. Students should do assignments that require thinking and creativity because they will be more successful in the future. By being creative, students will remember more of the content, rather than memorizing information and then forgetting it after the test is done.
For example, "Beyond their ineffectiveness as assessments, note that the act of administering (and emphasizing the results of) standardized tests can communicate some pointed lessons about the nature of learning. Because there is a premium placed on remembering facts, children may come to think that this is what really matters—and they may even come to develop a "quiz show" view of intelligence that confuses being smart with knowing a lot of stuff. Because the tests are timed, students may be encouraged to see intelligence as a function of how quickly people can do things. Because the tests often rely on a multiple-choice format, students may infer "that a right or wrong answer is available for all questions and problems" in life and that "someone else already knows the answer to [all these questions], so original interpretations are not expected; the task is to find or guess the right answer, rather than to engage in interpretive activity.”"
A takeaway that is important to remember is that students are learning to memorize information that will not be helpful to them in the long run. The information that students need to know should be important to the student and the student needs to find a way, that benefits them, to remember the content by being creative with different strategies. Standardized testing does not show what each of the students is capable of, so we need to find ways to show what our students can do!
Conclusion: How will this impact what you do in the classroom?
This will impact what I do in the classroom by finding different strategies to use with my students to help them take the tests to the best of their abilities. It is my goal to ensure that all the students receive the help that they deserve, not matter what it takes. I want to create strategies that will help the students succeed in the class.








